Cranberry juice and bladder infections: Can it really help?
Bladder infections, also known as urinary tract infections (UTIs), are common and particularly affect women. One of the most common causes of such infections is the bacteria Escherichia coli (E. coli), which attaches itself to the walls of the bladder and causes inflammation. In recent decades, cranberry juice has been promoted as a natural remedy for preventing bladder infections. But how exactly does the juice help, and what does research say about it?
How Cranberries Work
Cranberries contain a group of phytochemicals called proanthocyanidins (PACs). These PACs are particularly important to cranberries' preventive properties for bladder infections. Research suggests that PACs block the ability of E. coli to attach to the lining cells of the urinary tract. This means that the bacteria that often trigger bladder infections can be more easily flushed out of the urinary tract before they cause an infection.
E. coli binds to the mucous membrane of the bladder via so-called fimbriae, hair-like structures on the surface of the bacteria. PACs specifically inhibit the binding of the so-called P-fimbriae of E. coli to the bladder wall, making the bacteria less likely to cause an infection.
Research results on the effectiveness of cranberry products
Research on the effectiveness of cranberry juice in preventing bladder infections is extensive and has been reviewed many times over the past few decades. A 2023 systematic review and meta-analysis by the Cochrane Collaboration looked at how effective cranberry products really are. This study summarized 50 randomized controlled trials involving a total of 8,857 participants.
The results of this analysis suggest that cranberry products may reduce the risk of symptomatic and culture-confirmed urinary tract infections in certain groups of people. Cranberry products appear to have some preventive benefit, particularly in women who are prone to recurrent bladder infections, as well as in children and people who are prone to urinary tract infections due to medical procedures. In women with recurrent bladder infections, the risk of recurrent infection was reduced by about 26%.
However, no significant benefit was found for elderly people in care facilities, pregnant women and adults with neurogenic bladder emptying disorders. This shows that cranberry products are not equally suitable for every risk group.
Juice or tablets – which is better?
A common question is whether cranberry juice or cranberry tablets are more effective. According to the studies available, the difference between juice and capsules is not clear. However, cranberry juice can be a convenient option as it can be easily incorporated into daily life. Cranberry tablets, on the other hand, often contain a higher concentration of PACs and can therefore be a more effective option. Another problem with taking juice is that many commercially available juices contain large amounts of sugar, which can have other health disadvantages.
prevention of antibiotic resistance
Another benefit of cranberry products is their potential role in reducing the use of antibiotics. Bladder infections are often treated routinely with antibiotics, leading to an increase in antibiotic resistance - a global health problem. By reducing the risk of infections, cranberry products could help reduce the use of antibiotics and thus help to curb the development of resistance.
However, it is important to emphasize that cranberry products should not be considered a substitute for antibiotics in acute cystitis. Once an infection occurs, antibiotic treatment is usually necessary to avoid complications. Cranberries should rather be considered as a preventative measure.
side effects and tolerability
Cranberry products are generally well tolerated. Only a few side effects have been reported in studies. Gastrointestinal complaints such as diarrhea can occasionally occur, especially with excessive consumption of cranberry juice. However, the studies showed that the frequency of gastrointestinal side effects in people who consume cranberry products is not significantly higher than in those who take a placebo.
It is also important to note that cranberry juice in large amounts can lead to increased levels of oxalate in the urine. This may increase the risk of developing kidney stones, especially in people who are prone to kidney stones. For these individuals, cranberry tablets may be a safer option, as they tend to contain less oxalate than juice.
Who are cranberry products suitable for?
Current research suggests that cranberry products may be particularly helpful for women with recurrent urinary tract infections, children, and people at increased risk of infection after certain medical procedures. These groups may benefit from regular consumption of cranberry juice or tablets to reduce the risk of infection.
However, older people, pregnant women and people with certain bladder dysfunctions should not rely too much on the preventive properties of cranberry products, as studies do not indicate any significant benefits in these cases. In these cases, other preventive measures or treatments may be more effective.
In summary, cranberries can serve as a natural prevention option. Cranberry juice and cranberry tablets offer a promising natural option for preventing cystitis, especially for women with recurrent infections. Their PACs can prevent E. coli from attaching to the walls of the bladder, reducing the risk of infection. Research shows that they can have a moderate preventive effect in certain risk groups. Nevertheless, cranberry products should not be considered as a sole prevention or treatment method, but should be used in combination with other measures. Regular consumption can be a building block to prevent infections, but should always be seen in the context of individual health needs and in consultation with a doctor.
Sources:
